Excelium HR Alternative for Workers' Comp — Comp Ninjas
Excelium HR bundles workers' comp with payroll, HR, and benefits. Comp Ninjas is workers' comp only — instant online calculator, same-day certificate of insurance, bilingual EN/ES, and specialty coverage for roofing, towing, trucking, and other hard-to-place Florida industries.
Get My Instant Workers' Comp QuoteWhat Is Excelium HR and Who Is It For?
Excelium HR is a Miami-based Professional Employer Organization (PEO) that has been in business for over 20 years. Their model bundles workers' compensation, payroll processing, tax filing, HR administration, employee benefits, and 401(k) plans into a single service for small businesses with 1–50 employees. They serve construction, healthcare, hospitality, and professional services industries.
The Excelium HR model is designed for business owners who want to hand off all HR and payroll functions to a single vendor. Their phone number is (888) 996-2280 and they are based in Miami, FL. They advertise a 24-hour quote response time and offer pay-as-you-go workers' comp certificates through their PEO structure.
The limitation of the Excelium HR model for many Florida contractors is that workers' comp is bundled with payroll. To get workers' comp through Excelium HR, you must also move your payroll into their system. For contractors who already have a payroll provider they trust — or who simply want workers' comp coverage without changing their entire HR setup — this bundled requirement adds cost and complexity that may not be necessary.
Comp Ninjas takes a different approach: workers' compensation only, through a PEO structure, with no payroll or HR bundle required. You keep your existing payroll provider. You get an instant online premium calculator, same-day certificate of insurance, and specialty coverage for the hard-to-place industries that traditional carriers routinely decline — roofing, framing, towing, trucking, agriculture, home health, and staffing.
4 Reasons Florida Contractors Choose Comp Ninjas Over Excelium HR
Instant Online Premium Calculator
Excelium HR requires you to submit a form and wait up to 24 hours for a quote response. Comp Ninjas has a live online calculator — enter your payroll and class code, and you see your estimated annual premium immediately. No waiting, no phone tag.
Same-Day Certificate of Insurance
When you need to start a job tomorrow, a 24-hour quote window is too slow. Comp Ninjas issues certificates of insurance the same business day — often within hours. For contractors satisfying a GC's COI requirement, speed is everything.
Fully Bilingual English / Spanish
Every page, every form, every rate table on the Comp Ninjas website is available in both English and Spanish. Spanish-speaking contractors in Florida can get a full quote, review their rates, and understand their coverage — all in their preferred language.
Specialty Hard-to-Place Industries
Comp Ninjas specializes in the industries that traditional carriers decline: roofing, framing, demolition, towing, trucking, agriculture, home health, and staffing. We have dedicated rate tables with real 2026 FWCJUA rates for each industry and the PEO market access to bind coverage where others can't.
Comp Ninjas vs Excelium HR — Workers' Comp Comparison
| Feature | Comp Ninjas | Excelium HR |
|---|---|---|
| Service Focus | Workers' comp only — no bundle required | Full PEO bundle: payroll + HR + benefits + workers' comp |
| Quote Speed | Instant online calculator + same-day COI | 24-hour quote response window |
| Setup Cost | $875 flat one-time setup fee | Not publicly disclosed — bundled pricing |
| Payroll Required | No — keep your existing payroll provider | Yes — payroll must move to Excelium HR system |
| Hard-to-Place Industries | Roofing, towing, trucking, ag, home health, staffing | Construction and trades (general) |
| Bilingual Support | Full English + Spanish website and forms | English primary; Spanish-speaking staff in Miami |
| Online Rate Calculator | Yes — instant premium estimate online | No — form submission required |
| Minimum Employees | None — owner-only and 1-employee OK | 1–50 employees (per their website) |
| Year-End Audit | Eliminated — pay-as-you-go on actual payroll | Eliminated — PEO structure |
| Location | Pineland, FL — statewide Florida coverage | Miami, FL — statewide Florida coverage |
| License | FL License L132181 (Bright Coast Insurance Inc.) | Licensed PEO in Florida |
Information about Excelium HR sourced from exceliumhr.com as of July 2026. Comp Ninjas is a DBA of Bright Coast Insurance Inc., FL License L132181.
When Excelium HR Makes Sense — and When It Doesn't
Excelium HR May Be Right If…
- You want one vendor to handle payroll, HR, benefits, AND workers' comp
- You have 10–50 employees and want full HR outsourcing
- You're in a standard industry with no hard-to-place classification issues
- You're willing to move your payroll to their platform
- A 24-hour quote response time is acceptable for your timeline
Choose Comp Ninjas If…
- You need workers' comp only — no payroll bundle
- You need a certificate of insurance today or tomorrow
- You're in roofing, towing, trucking, agriculture, home health, or staffing
- You want to see your premium estimate instantly online
- You prefer bilingual (English/Spanish) service
- You have 1–10 employees or are owner-only
- You've been declined by traditional carriers
Workers' Comp for Hard-to-Place Florida Industries
Excelium HR vs Comp Ninjas — Common Questions
Is Excelium HR good for small Florida contractors?
Excelium HR is a full-service PEO based in Miami that bundles workers' comp, payroll, HR administration, benefits, and 401(k) into a single package for businesses with 1–50 employees. That bundled approach works well for businesses that want a single vendor to manage all HR functions. However, if you only need workers' compensation — for example, a roofing contractor who already handles payroll separately — you are paying for services you don't need. Comp Ninjas provides workers' comp only through a PEO structure, with no payroll or HR bundle required.
How does Comp Ninjas compare to Excelium HR for workers' comp?
Both Comp Ninjas and Excelium HR use a PEO structure for workers' comp, which means pay-as-you-go premiums, no large upfront deposit, and no year-end audit. The key difference is scope: Excelium HR requires you to bring your payroll into their system as part of the bundle. Comp Ninjas is workers' comp only — you keep your existing payroll provider and simply add PEO workers' comp coverage. Comp Ninjas also offers an instant online premium calculator, same-day certificates, and bilingual (English/Spanish) support.
Does Excelium HR cover hard-to-place industries like roofing or towing?
Excelium HR's website lists construction and trades as industries they serve. However, their primary focus is on the full HR bundle. Comp Ninjas specializes exclusively in hard-to-place workers' comp industries — roofing, framing, demolition, towing, trucking, agriculture, home health, and staffing — and has dedicated rate tables and industry-specific expertise for each. If you've been declined by traditional carriers, Comp Ninjas' specialty PEO markets are specifically designed for your industry.
How fast can I get a certificate of insurance compared to Excelium HR?
Excelium HR advertises a 24-hour quote response time. Comp Ninjas issues certificates of insurance the same business day — often within hours of completing the application. For contractors who need to start a job tomorrow or satisfy a GC's COI requirement today, Comp Ninjas' same-day issuance is a critical advantage.
Does Comp Ninjas offer bilingual workers' comp support like Excelium HR?
Yes. Comp Ninjas is a fully bilingual (English/Spanish) workers' comp service. Every page of the website, every quote form, and every rate table is available in both languages. This is particularly important for Spanish-speaking contractors in Florida, Texas, and California who need to understand their coverage options clearly. Excelium HR is based in Miami and serves Spanish-speaking clients, but their online resources are primarily in English.
What is the setup cost at Comp Ninjas vs Excelium HR?
Comp Ninjas charges a flat $875 one-time setup fee with no ongoing monthly HR or payroll fees. Excelium HR does not publish pricing publicly — their quote process requires a 24-hour response window and typically bundles workers' comp with payroll and HR administration fees. For a small contractor who only needs workers' comp, the Comp Ninjas model is significantly more cost-transparent.
Can I switch from Excelium HR to Comp Ninjas?
Yes. If you are currently using Excelium HR for workers' comp and want to separate your workers' comp from your HR/payroll bundle, Comp Ninjas can coordinate the transition. We'll review your current coverage, identify the right PEO program for your industry, and issue a new certificate of insurance. Most transitions are completed within 1–2 business days.
Does Comp Ninjas handle payroll like Excelium HR?
No — and that is intentional. Comp Ninjas focuses exclusively on workers' compensation through a PEO structure. We do not offer payroll processing, HR administration, or benefits management. If you want a single vendor for all HR functions, Excelium HR may be a better fit. If you already have a payroll provider you're happy with and just need workers' comp coverage — especially for a hard-to-place industry — Comp Ninjas is the focused, faster solution.
Ready to Get Covered?
Same-day COI. No large down payment. Bilingual support. Get your free quote in 2 minutes.